Stop using optimally-tiled images in external memory tests (#2349)

Support for optimally-tiled images and tiling inference in general is
implementation-defined. It should not be relied upon in the CTS.

Also build the code base as C++17 for std::optional. Many Khronos
projects are now using C++17 and the transition in the CTS is IMO
overdue.

Signed-off-by: Kevin Petit <kevin.petit@arm.com>
This commit is contained in:
Kévin Petit
2025-04-15 18:28:35 +01:00
committed by GitHub
parent e96edaef8b
commit 829e91663a
7 changed files with 68 additions and 36 deletions

View File

@@ -705,13 +705,17 @@ clExternalMemoryImage::clExternalMemoryImage(
std::vector<cl_mem_properties> extMemProperties1;
cl_device_id devList[] = { deviceId, NULL };
VulkanImageTiling vulkanImageTiling =
vkClExternalMemoryHandleTilingAssumption(
deviceId, externalMemoryHandleType, &errcode_ret);
auto vulkanImageTiling = vkClExternalMemoryHandleTilingAssumption(
deviceId, externalMemoryHandleType, &errcode_ret);
if (CL_SUCCESS != errcode_ret)
{
throw std::runtime_error("Failed to query OpenCL tiling mode");
}
if (vulkanImageTiling == std::nullopt)
{
throw std::runtime_error(
"Could not find image tiling supported by both Vulkan and OpenCL");
}
#ifdef _WIN32
if (!is_extension_available(devList[0], "cl_khr_external_memory_win32"))
@@ -1206,12 +1210,11 @@ cl_external_memory_handle_type_khr vkToOpenCLExternalMemoryHandleType(
return 0;
}
VulkanImageTiling vkClExternalMemoryHandleTilingAssumption(
std::optional<VulkanImageTiling> vkClExternalMemoryHandleTilingAssumption(
cl_device_id deviceId,
VulkanExternalMemoryHandleType vkExternalMemoryHandleType, int *error_ret)
{
size_t size = 0;
VulkanImageTiling mode = VULKAN_IMAGE_TILING_OPTIMAL;
assert(error_ret
!= nullptr); // errcode_ret is not optional, it must be checked
@@ -1222,12 +1225,12 @@ VulkanImageTiling vkClExternalMemoryHandleTilingAssumption(
0, nullptr, &size);
if (*error_ret != CL_SUCCESS)
{
return mode;
return std::nullopt;
}
if (size == 0)
{
return mode;
return std::nullopt;
}
std::vector<cl_external_memory_handle_type_khr> assume_linear_types(
@@ -1239,7 +1242,7 @@ VulkanImageTiling vkClExternalMemoryHandleTilingAssumption(
size, assume_linear_types.data(), nullptr);
if (*error_ret != CL_SUCCESS)
{
return mode;
return std::nullopt;
}
if (std::find(
@@ -1247,8 +1250,8 @@ VulkanImageTiling vkClExternalMemoryHandleTilingAssumption(
vkToOpenCLExternalMemoryHandleType(vkExternalMemoryHandleType))
!= assume_linear_types.end())
{
mode = VULKAN_IMAGE_TILING_LINEAR;
return VULKAN_IMAGE_TILING_LINEAR;
}
return mode;
return std::nullopt;
}

View File

@@ -26,6 +26,8 @@
#include <OpenCL/cl_ext.h>
#endif
#include <optional>
#define CREATE_OPENCL_SEMAPHORE(clSemaphore, vkSemaphore, ctx, handleType, \
devIdx, createExportable) \
if (!(createExportable \
@@ -187,7 +189,7 @@ public:
extern void init_cl_vk_ext(cl_platform_id, cl_uint num_devices,
cl_device_id *deviceIds);
VulkanImageTiling vkClExternalMemoryHandleTilingAssumption(
std::optional<VulkanImageTiling> vkClExternalMemoryHandleTilingAssumption(
cl_device_id deviceId,
VulkanExternalMemoryHandleType vkExternalMemoryHandleType, int *error_ret);

View File

@@ -485,7 +485,7 @@ public:
VulkanExternalMemoryHandleType externalMemoryHandleType =
VULKAN_EXTERNAL_MEMORY_HANDLE_TYPE_NONE,
VulkanImageCreateFlag imageCreateFlags = VULKAN_IMAGE_CREATE_FLAG_NONE,
VulkanImageTiling imageTiling = VULKAN_IMAGE_TILING_OPTIMAL,
VulkanImageTiling imageTiling = VULKAN_IMAGE_TILING_LINEAR,
VulkanImageUsage imageUsage =
VULKAN_IMAGE_USAGE_SAMPLED_STORAGE_TRANSFER_SRC_DST,
VulkanSharingMode sharingMode = VULKAN_SHARING_MODE_EXCLUSIVE);

View File

@@ -216,14 +216,19 @@ struct ConsistencyExternalImageTest : public VulkanTestBase
getSupportedVulkanExternalMemoryHandleTypeList(
vkDevice->getPhysicalDevice())[0];
VulkanImageTiling vulkanImageTiling =
vkClExternalMemoryHandleTilingAssumption(
device, vkExternalMemoryHandleType, &errNum);
auto vulkanImageTiling = vkClExternalMemoryHandleTilingAssumption(
device, vkExternalMemoryHandleType, &errNum);
ASSERT_SUCCESS(errNum, "Failed to query OpenCL tiling mode");
if (vulkanImageTiling == std::nullopt)
{
log_info("No image tiling supported by both Vulkan and OpenCL "
"could be found\n");
return TEST_SKIPPED_ITSELF;
}
VulkanImage2D vkImage2D = VulkanImage2D(
*vkDevice, VULKAN_FORMAT_R8G8B8A8_UNORM, width, height,
vulkanImageTiling, 1, vkExternalMemoryHandleType);
*vulkanImageTiling, 1, vkExternalMemoryHandleType);
const VulkanMemoryTypeList& memoryTypeList =
vkImage2D.getMemoryTypeList();

View File

@@ -73,14 +73,20 @@ struct ConsistencyExternalImage1DTest : public VulkanTestBase
getSupportedVulkanExternalMemoryHandleTypeList(
vkDevice->getPhysicalDevice())[0];
VulkanImageTiling vulkanImageTiling =
vkClExternalMemoryHandleTilingAssumption(
device, vkExternalMemoryHandleType, &errNum);
auto vulkanImageTiling = vkClExternalMemoryHandleTilingAssumption(
device, vkExternalMemoryHandleType, &errNum);
ASSERT_SUCCESS(errNum, "Failed to query OpenCL tiling mode");
if (vulkanImageTiling == std::nullopt)
{
log_info("No image tiling supported by both Vulkan and OpenCL "
"could be found\n");
return TEST_SKIPPED_ITSELF;
}
VulkanImage1D vkImage1D =
VulkanImage1D(*vkDevice, VULKAN_FORMAT_R8G8B8A8_UNORM, width,
vulkanImageTiling, 1, vkExternalMemoryHandleType);
*vulkanImageTiling, 1, vkExternalMemoryHandleType);
const VulkanMemoryTypeList& memoryTypeList =
vkImage1D.getMemoryTypeList();

View File

@@ -76,14 +76,19 @@ struct ConsistencyExternalImage3DTest : public VulkanTestBase
getSupportedVulkanExternalMemoryHandleTypeList(
vkDevice->getPhysicalDevice())[0];
VulkanImageTiling vulkanImageTiling =
vkClExternalMemoryHandleTilingAssumption(
device, vkExternalMemoryHandleType, &errNum);
auto vulkanImageTiling = vkClExternalMemoryHandleTilingAssumption(
device, vkExternalMemoryHandleType, &errNum);
ASSERT_SUCCESS(errNum, "Failed to query OpenCL tiling mode");
if (vulkanImageTiling == std::nullopt)
{
log_info("No image tiling supported by both Vulkan and OpenCL "
"could be found\n");
return TEST_SKIPPED_ITSELF;
}
VulkanImage3D vkImage3D = VulkanImage3D(
*vkDevice, VULKAN_FORMAT_R8G8B8A8_UNORM, width, height, depth,
vulkanImageTiling, 1, vkExternalMemoryHandleType);
*vulkanImageTiling, 1, vkExternalMemoryHandleType);
const VulkanMemoryTypeList& memoryTypeList =
vkImage3D.getMemoryTypeList();

View File

@@ -368,16 +368,22 @@ int run_test_with_two_queue(
}
log_info("External memory handle type: %d \n",
vkExternalMemoryHandleType);
VulkanImageTiling vulkanImageTiling =
auto vulkanImageTiling =
vkClExternalMemoryHandleTilingAssumption(
deviceId,
vkExternalMemoryHandleTypeList[emhtIdx], &err);
ASSERT_SUCCESS(err,
"Failed to query OpenCL tiling mode");
if (vulkanImageTiling == std::nullopt)
{
log_info("No image tiling supported by both Vulkan "
"and OpenCL could be found\n");
return TEST_SKIPPED_ITSELF;
}
VulkanImage2D vkDummyImage2D(
vkDevice, vkFormatList[0], widthList[0],
heightList[0], vulkanImageTiling, 1,
heightList[0], *vulkanImageTiling, 1,
vkExternalMemoryHandleType);
const VulkanMemoryTypeList &memoryTypeList =
vkDummyImage2D.getMemoryTypeList();
@@ -405,7 +411,7 @@ int run_test_with_two_queue(
{
VulkanImage2D vkImage2D(
vkDevice, vkFormat, width, height,
vulkanImageTiling, numMipLevels,
*vulkanImageTiling, numMipLevels,
vkExternalMemoryHandleType);
ASSERT_LEQ(vkImage2D.getSize(), maxImage2DSize);
totalImageMemSize =
@@ -414,7 +420,7 @@ int run_test_with_two_queue(
}
VulkanImage2DList vkImage2DList(
num2DImages, vkDevice, vkFormat, width, height,
vulkanImageTiling, numMipLevels,
*vulkanImageTiling, numMipLevels,
vkExternalMemoryHandleType);
for (size_t bIdx = 0; bIdx < num2DImages; bIdx++)
{
@@ -436,7 +442,7 @@ int run_test_with_two_queue(
vkDevice, vkImage2DList);
VulkanImage2DList vkImage2DList2(
num2DImages, vkDevice, vkFormat, width, height,
vulkanImageTiling, numMipLevels,
*vulkanImageTiling, numMipLevels,
vkExternalMemoryHandleType);
for (size_t bIdx = 0; bIdx < num2DImages; bIdx++)
{
@@ -982,16 +988,21 @@ int run_test_with_one_queue(
continue;
}
VulkanImageTiling vulkanImageTiling =
auto vulkanImageTiling =
vkClExternalMemoryHandleTilingAssumption(
deviceId,
vkExternalMemoryHandleTypeList[emhtIdx], &err);
test_error_and_cleanup(
err, CLEANUP, "Failed to query OpenCL tiling mode");
if (vulkanImageTiling == std::nullopt)
{
log_info("No image tiling supported by both Vulkan "
"and OpenCL could be found\n");
return TEST_SKIPPED_ITSELF;
}
VulkanImage2D vkDummyImage2D(
vkDevice, vkFormatList[0], widthList[0],
heightList[0], vulkanImageTiling, 1,
heightList[0], *vulkanImageTiling, 1,
vkExternalMemoryHandleType);
const VulkanMemoryTypeList &memoryTypeList =
vkDummyImage2D.getMemoryTypeList();
@@ -1018,7 +1029,7 @@ int run_test_with_one_queue(
{
VulkanImage2D vkImage2D(
vkDevice, vkFormat, width, height,
vulkanImageTiling, numMipLevels,
*vulkanImageTiling, numMipLevels,
vkExternalMemoryHandleType);
ASSERT_LEQ(vkImage2D.getSize(), maxImage2DSize);
totalImageMemSize =
@@ -1027,7 +1038,7 @@ int run_test_with_one_queue(
}
VulkanImage2DList vkImage2DList(
num2DImages, vkDevice, vkFormat, width, height,
vulkanImageTiling, numMipLevels,
*vulkanImageTiling, numMipLevels,
vkExternalMemoryHandleType);
for (size_t bIdx = 0; bIdx < vkImage2DList.size();
bIdx++)
@@ -1053,7 +1064,7 @@ int run_test_with_one_queue(
VulkanImage2DList vkImage2DList2(
num2DImages, vkDevice, vkFormat, width, height,
vulkanImageTiling, numMipLevels,
*vulkanImageTiling, numMipLevels,
vkExternalMemoryHandleType);
for (size_t bIdx = 0; bIdx < vkImage2DList2.size();
bIdx++)